The Last Guest House by Caroline Mitchell

“The Last Guest House” by Caroline Mitchell, set in the Isle of Skye, presents an intriguing premise and attempts to weave a complex narrative around a series of suspenseful events. The novel, featuring DC Nicola McKenna in a supposedly restful getaway turned into a fraught experience at The Loch House, aimed to blend elements of suspense and thrill in a unique setting.

However, my reading experience was a mixed bag. While the book sets up a promising storyline filled with potential twists and suspense, it fell short in certain aspects. The plot, in several instances, appeared forced and somewhat unbelievable, detracting from the immersive experience typically expected from thrillers.

Character development was another area where the book didn’t fully deliver for me. I found it challenging to establish a connection with the characters, including the protagonist. A lack of depth or relatability in character portrayal can sometimes create a barrier in fully engaging with the story, which was my experience with this novel.

While there were parts of the book that were okay and certain elements of suspense that were handled well, overall, the book didn’t quite hit the mark for me, warranting a three-star rating. It might appeal to readers who enjoy a straightforward thriller and are less concerned with plausibility or deep character connections.

Try it for yourself and see what you think.

This review is based on a complimentary copy from the publisher, provided through NetGalley. All opinions are my own.